Harvey Marcelin

Harvey Marcelin
Born	Harvey A. Marcelin (1938-05-21) May 21, 1938 Harlem, New York City, New York, U.S.
Other names	Marceline Harvey
Criminal status	In custody, awaiting trial
Conviction(s)	Bonds: Murder Miranda: Manslaughter Leyden: Awaiting trial
Criminal penalty	Bonds: Life imprisonment with parole Miranda: 12 years imprisonment Leyden: Awaiting trial
Details
Victims	2–3
Span of crimes	1963–2022
Country	United States
State(s)	New York
Date apprehended	For the final time in April 2022

Harvey A. Marcelin (born May 21, 1938), also known as Marceline Harvey, is an American murderer and suspected serial killer.

Convicted of murdering two girlfriends in New York in separate instances over several decades, both of which were committed after being released from prison. She is currently awaiting trial for a third murder committed under allegedly similar circumstances.

Early life

Harvey A. Marcelin was born on May 21, 1938, in Harlem, New York City, the only child of a shipping clerk and a seamstress who later moved to Washington Heights. According to later interviews, Marcelin was spoiled by both of her parents and grew up in a relatively stable environment.

When she was ten, her father passed away, after which Marcelin had to be brought up by her mother. She attended kindergarten and later a Catholic school run by the St. Aloysius Catholic Church in Harlem where, according to Marcelin, she was sexually abused, whipped and forced to eat expired food by the nuns. As a result, she experienced many emotional and behavioral problems, and by her teenage years, she had begun to engage in sexually deviant behavior.

By her own admission, Marcelin first began cross-dressing in 1951 after attending a Halloween party, after which she reportedly began suffering from gender dysphoria and had sex with a man for the first time. Around this time, her mental health began to decline rapidly, with the then-14-year-old being accused of attempting to sexually assault an 8-year-old girl in 1952. Not long after, she was admitted to a psychiatric hospital in the summer of that year for evaluation on behalf of Catholic Charities USA. The medical reports noted that at that time, Marcelin was a noted truant who committed thefts and regularly engaged in sexual activity with men and women alike. Upon her release, Marcelin returned to school and graduated in 1956, but soon returned to her criminal lifestyle.

Hospitalization

In 1957, she was charged with a burglary, convicted and spent several months in the county jail. After being released, Marcelin spent the period from the late 1950s to 1963 living with her mother and working as a copy machine operator, as she had difficulty finding a stable source of income due to her mental illness and drug addiction. Despite her repeated internments, psychiatrists could never reach a consensus on what exactly she suffered from.

On April 9, 1962, Marcelin voluntarily sought treatment at the Bellevue Hospital, where she remained until April 16, whereupon she was discharged to her wife's custody. Tests conducted during this time established that she showed signs of chronic schizophrenia, delusions and a paranoid personality.

Previous murders

Jacqueline Bonds

In the early 1960s, Marcelin married a woman named Florence Jackson, but their relationship proved troublesome, as Marcelin often cheated on Florence with other women. In early 1962, Marcelin met 24-year-old Jacqueline Bonds, with whom she soon began an intimate relationship. However, Bonds soon began to accuse her of being aggressive and eventually ended their affair – this caused Marcelin to start stalking and sexually harassing her, as well as threaten to "get her" in front of her mother.

In March 1963, Marcelin, along with her newest girlfriend, Clementine Benifield, were arrested in Brooklyn on charges of attempted rape, second-degree assault and burglary. After her arrest, she claimed that Bonds was with them at the time of the crimes, and Bonds was promptly detained, but when it later became clear that she played a small role, the prosecutors offered her a plea deal - in exchange for testifying against her co-defendants, she would be granted immunity from prosecution. While the investigation was still underway, Marcelin was released from prison after her mother paid her bail.

On April 18, Marcelin went to Bonds' apartment on 2216 Eight Avenue in Manhattan and got into an argument with her in the hallway, during which Marcelin pulled out a .32 caliber revolver and shot her. Bonds then ran into her bedroom, but was shot again twice, staggering and collapsing into the living room, where she succumbed to her injuries. She was arrested shortly afterwards and taken to the Bellevue Hospital for a psychiatric assessment. The examining psychiatrists ruled that while she suffered from a schizoid personality disorder with sociopathic traits, Marcelin was sane and could stand trial.

Trial and incarceration

At the trial, Marcelin was found guilty of murdering Bonds on November 18, 1963, and was sentenced to a life term with a chance of parole after a jury deadlocked on the death penalty. When asked why she did it, she claimed that she killed Bonds out of jealousy, since Bonds was beautiful and popular and Marcelin did not want her to be with other men.

After her conviction, Marcelin was transferred between the various prison facilities across New York. In 1971, she participated in the Attica Prison riot, which would later become one of the most famous and significant events of the prisoners' rights movement by bringing more attention to their demands for political rights and better living conditions. The riot caused a public outcry across the nation and attracted media attention after it was violently suppressed by the police. After the riot ended, a number of inmates were transferred to other prisons, including Marcelin. In November of that year, she was interviewed by reporters and described what had happened, stating that the rioters had been bullied by prison staff at the facilities they were transferred to.

For many years, her parole applications were repeatedly denied due to her aggressive behavior towards women and sending inappropriate letters to hospital volunteers. In May 1984, after serving more than 21 years in prison, Marcelin was granted parole with lifetime supervision and released.

Anna Miranda

After her release, Marcelin returned to New York City, where she found lodging in a room at the Cambridge Residence Hotel in Harlem. Due to financial difficulties, she had trouble finding employment after her release and earned a living by renting out her hotel room. She also spent a great amount of time amongst prostitutes and pimps, as well as homeless people who struggled from various forms of alcoholism and drug addictions.

In early 1985, she met 29-year-old Anna Laura Serrera Miranda, a heroin addict and prostitute who soon became her lodger and roommate. On October 29, Marcelin, who had recently ingested crack cocaine, stabbed Miranda to death during an argument, after which she dismembered the corpse, put it into black plastic garbage bags and then scattered them around various areas of Central Park. She was quickly arrested after the remains were discovered, as her neighbor Roberto Romano had seen her carrying blood-soaked bags the day after the murder.

Trial and incarceration

During interrogations, Marcelin fully admitted to killing Miranda, but insisted she had done so in self-defense. According to Marcelin, they had gotten into an argument because Miranda stopped paying her rent and stole several items from the hotel room, including a flute and cufflinks. She claimed that she was never aggressive with Miranda and cared for her, while she often left for days at a time without explanation. An autopsy concluded that Miranda had been stabbed a total of 33 times.

Because she had committed a felony, Marcelin's parole was revoked and she was returned to prison to continue serving her life term. In 1986, she was convicted of killing Miranda, but the charges were downgraded to manslaughter following a guilty plea, adding only 12 years to her existing life term. She was allowed to apply for parole, and as a result, from 1985 to 2019, she applied for parole a total of 15 times, but was always denied due to the severity of her crimes. Some of the arguments for her parole ranged from asking for a new trial to getting involved in a class action lawsuit for her involvement in the Attica prison riot, as well as labeling an all-female parole board "sexist" for denying her parole.

In 1993, while incarcerated at the Auburn Correctional Facility, Marcelin met with a transsexual inmate who advised her to start taking the hormone therapy medication Premarin, after which Marcelin completely dedicated herself to transitioning. In 2019, she was finally granted parole by the Parole Board after they took into account her advanced age; successful completion of multiple rehabilitation programs; graduate degree in computer science and technology; and letters from various volunteer organizations that pledged to provide her with housing and employment if released.

Marcelin was granted parole a second time on August 7, 2019, at the age of 81, having spent nearly 55 years incarcerated since the murder of Jacqueline Bonds.

Murder of Susan Leyden

Meeting and falling out

After her release, the 81-year-old Marcelin returned to New York City, now presenting as a transsexual woman and going under the name "Marceline Harvey". In late 2019, while visiting the Tompkins Square Park in East Village, she met Susan Leyden, a 68-year-old lesbian living in a Fort Greene-based homeless shelter for LGBT people. At the time she met Marcelin, Leyden suffered from an undisclosed mental illness and was addicted to drugs, but was formerly a successful entrepreneur who owned a jewelry store in Fort Lee, New Jersey, which she had to abandon in the late 2010s due to her declining mental health.

Soon after they became acquainted with one another, they started living at the shelter and developed romantic feelings for one another. A few months later, Marcelin and Leyden found housing in Manhattan, which they paid for with their various welfare checks. Despite her advanced age and long imprisonment, Marcelin was able to quickly adapt to social life and to the Internet, establishing accounts on social networks such as Facebook. She also began to live an active social life, spending much of her free time outdoors, trying to get to know women and having intimate relationships. On her social media accounts, Marcelin posted pictures of herself with makeup and various female wigs. At around this time, two other women became close friends with her and often came to the apartment she shared with Leyden.

Discovery and arrest

In late February 2022, investigators allege that Marcelin stabbed Leyden to death and later dismembered her corpse, parts of which were subsequently scattered around various blocks in New York City. Leyden's torso was found wrapped in a multicolored bag with a flower decal by a passer-by in a shopping cart several blocks away from the apartment on March 3, prompting police to question her about the gruesome discovery.

On the following day, Marcelin was arrested at the apartment following a police search which uncovered Leyden's severed head, a power saw, and bloody sheets. Police also reviewed surveillance footage that covered the entryway of the apartment building where Leyden and Marcelin lived, with the footage showing that Leyden was last seen alive entering the building on February 27. In the following days, only Marcelin was seen on the footage, and until her arrest, she was seen traveling with a purse that belonged to Leyden. In addition to this, surveillance footage from a local hardware store taken on March 1 showed her and an unidentified woman purchasing a power saw, trash bags and cleaning supplies. On the next day, footage from a grocery store showed Marcelin riding a mobility scooter with what appeared to be a severed human leg on the seat, which was clearly visible when she got off the scooter to browse the merchandise.

Charges and theories about motive

On March 30, 2022, Marcelin was charged with second-degree murder and concealment of a corpse, to which she pleaded not guilty. Police have thus far been unable to establish a motive for the murder. An examination of Marcelin's social media accounts revealed that she initially established contact with Leyden in 2019, and throughout 2020 and 2021, she repeatedly used Leyden's photos as her social media profile picture. In October 2021, just months before Leyden's murder, Marcelin responded to a comment made by Leyden by simply saying "Love personified". Police speculate that the feelings were not mutual and that Leyden was actually afraid of Marcelin and wanted to end their relationship, which in turn could have further motivated the murder. In November 2020, Marcelin uploaded a photo of a young blonde woman as her Facebook profile's main picture - in response, Leyden posted a negative comment, calling her a "freak".

Marcelin's version of events

After her arrest, Marcelin was interviewed in Rikers Island by a reporter for The New York Post, during which she gave details of her biography and her version of events. In the interview, she admitted responsibility for the murders of Bonds and Miranda, but categorically denied killing Leyden, instead blaming one of the female acquaintances who frequented the apartment. She claimed that the two women were sexually attracted to her and were jealous of Leyden, but as she did not reciprocate, they decided to kill Leyden while she was away and frame her for the murder.

Marcelin also said that she has a split personality, with one identity periodically replacing the other. She described the female identity, Marceline Harvey, as a peaceful, caring lesbian, while the male one - Harvey - was a "bad guy" who was misogynistic, a deviant and very aggressive. A number of acquaintances of Marcelin who were interviewed at a later date expressed disgust and disbelief in regards to the crime committed, with a friend of Leyden's saying that whoever the killer was, they deserved either life without parole or the death penalty.

Trial

Marcelin's trial for the murder of Susan Leyden began on March 1, 2024, and is currently ongoing.

In the media

• NBC New York TV report — The Timeline of Harvey Marcelin.

External links

• Marcelin v. Mancusi (1963)